This New York high school football assistant coach gave the administration his two cents and then decided to split following a controversial eligibility mistake that ended a perfect season.
Middletown High School assistant Isaac Cayetano publicly questioned the school for its role in not preventing the mistake that allowed an ineligible player to participate in a playoff game, leading to the school’s postseason disqualification and head coach Tim Strenfel’s resignation.
After his critical interview with News 12, Cayetano submitted his letter of resignation to the school after this experience “left an awful taste in my mouth.”
“Can you blame (Strenfel) for not knowing the rule? Absolutely. You can blame him. You can blame me. You can blame everyone on the staff and in that room,” Cayetano said. “However, we have bosses as well. We have people who are supposed to educate us.”
During its Nov. 6 Section IX Class AA semifinal win over Valley Central, Middletown used a kicker for 53 seconds in the game who did not meet postseason eligibility criteria.
The kicker, who had been recruited off the soccer team, was deemed an “ineligible kickoff specialist” after not being listed on the roster for three regular-season games, a mistake that would-be championship opponent Newburgh Free Academy reportedly noticed and relayed to Valley Central, which notified the league, according to midhudsonnews.com.
The school district reportedly said the player had participated in only eight kickoffs but did not score for Middletown, which had improved to 10-0 with the blowout win.
Cayetano told News 12 that Strenfel received approval to add the player to the roster and added that athletic director Justin Sturge and the District IX consultant should have known the rule too.
He further told the outlet that Sturge “made” the postseason roster and referred to it as another missed opportunity to catch the error.
The school acknowledged its mistake but filed an emergency petition and argued that the students should not be punished for adults’ errors, calling the ruling “arbitrary and capricious,” per the outlet.
The Orange County school ultimately withdrew its petition last Friday.
Strenfel, in his 10th season, then tendered his resignation earlier this week, although he had been considering doing so previously, per midhudsonews.com.
The school district is also investigating the matter to see what went wrong, per News 12.
Following the airing of his comments Wednesday on News 12, Cayetano filed his resignation to the district with a Nov. 18 date.
He praised Strenfel in the letter, especially complimenting him for how he cared for his players and especially the minorities on the roster.
“This experience has left an awful taste in my mouth. It was hard to watch, hard to understand and hard to accept,” he wrote. “I believe there was more we could have done and that too many important concerns were left unaddressed. Our players deserve more. I expected more.
“If a situation involving a coach with Tim’s character and commitment can end this way, with our boys paying the price for avoidable mistakes by adults, I want no part of continuing under those circumstances.”
He further wrote that they ask the players to take responsibility for their mistakes and “face difficult consequences,” and the adults must “meet the same standard.”
“If we expect our kids to ‘live in the fire,’ we must be willing to live there ourselves,” he wrote.
Cayetano concluded stating that the trust he had in Strenfel was built over two years but “I cannot simply transfer that trust to whoever may be hired next.”
“I do not have confidence that a new hire will care for and love our boys with the same commitment or bring the same understanding the young men that this program serves, particularly our black and brown players,” Cayetano wrote.
“After this experience, I am not willing to continue under another head coach.’













