Another old-school LA institution has bitten the dust.

Palermo Italian Restaurant, the longtime Los Feliz favorite known for its Sicilian-style comfort food, is closing permanently following the unexpected death of its larger-than-life founder, Tony Fanara.

“The reality is that none of us could replace him,” Michelle wrote in a private Facebook post. “Dad was larger than life. Even the three of us together couldn’t make one of him.”

Fanara, 79, died unexpectedly on July 10, while the restaurant was already closed for its annual summer vacation. Palermo had shut its doors July 1 and never reopened.

His family ultimately decided there was no way to carry on the business without him.

“The decision to close Palermo permanently and put the property up for sale was made by my mom, my brothers, and me.”

“It wasn’t an easy decision, but it was the right one for our family,” Michelle wrote, according to The Eastsider.

Fanara founded Palermo at its Vermont Avenue location in the early 1980s, building a neighborhood fixture that served generations of customers.

For Michelle, the restaurant was practically a second home from birth.

“It’s where my parents met, where my brothers and I grew up, and where so many of my childhood memories were made,” she wrote. “I was the baby being passed around at the grand opening of the Vermont Avenue location. It was also the first job for all three of us.”

The restaurant’s throwback atmosphere was part of its charm, with dark vinyl booths, map-of-Italy paper placemats, stained glass and murals depicting Sicilian seascapes giving the place the feel of a 1970s time capsule.

The $12 million listing includes two lots totaling approximately 14,000 square feet, an 8,056-square-foot fully equipped restaurant and a parking area.

Prospective buyers won’t get a look inside until early February 2027, according to the listing.

The closure has prompted an outpouring of nostalgia among locals.

One Reddit commenter noted that Fanara’s children had built careers of their own rather than take over the family business, adding that the family had repeatedly encouraged him to retire.

Another lamented the disappearance of neighborhood institutions, writing, “We’re losing too many mainstays. The cost of everything is too damn high.”

Share.