Plant-based foods may have a dirty little secret.
A new study that examined 212 vegan or vegetarian foods and drinks found that every single one contained fungal toxins called mycotoxins.
These are a broad group of toxins produced by fungi and molds that occur naturally in many foods like grains, legumes and fruits.
Importantly, some foods had much higher rates of contamination than others — and some had more concerning toxins in them.
Researchers in Italy, Spain and the UK bought a selection of plant-based products from shops around Britain. In total, they tested 92 plant-based meat alternatives and 120 plant-based milks.
Every single product had mycotoxins, but plant-based meat alternatives were more contaminated than milks — especially with toxins that come from Fusarium fungi.
Over 93% of plant-based meat samples had enniatin A and enniatin A1, which some studies suggest could build up in key organs like our brain, lungs and heart.
Almost all (98.9%) had beauvericin, which some studies suggest could cause cellular stress and potentially affect our brain. The effect of both types of toxins is just starting to be understood.
What’s in your alt milk?
Plant-based milks were also high in mycotoxins. The worst were oat-based drinks, which had the most variety in mycotoxins detected. All samples contained beauvericin, and 94.7% contained HT-2 toxin, which we know much more about.
HT-2 toxin can cause a potentially fatal food-borne illness called alimentary toxic aleukia — in an outbreak in the USSR in the late 1930s to early 1940s, this killed 60% of the people it infected. Research also shows it can affect the joints, causing pain and stiffness. There’s some evidence this toxin was even used as a biological weapon in the late 70s and early 80s.
About 90% of soy drinks had ochratoxin, which affects the kidneys and is classified as a Group 2B possible human carcinogen. Almond and other nut-based drinks had lower contamination levels than the other two plant-based milks but still contained beauvericin and enniatin toxins.
How bad is this really?
Although the researchers detected mycotoxins in every product tested, the concentrations were generally low and fell below regulatory limits.
The bigger concern is the potential health effects of repeated, cumulative exposure to multiple mycotoxins, particularly because scientists don’t fully understand how these toxins interact in the body.
“Such a large co-occurrence could lead to potential health risks that should be further evaluated,” they wrote. The effects could compound or make each other worse, as was seen in lab settings, they note.
Why is the contamination happening?
Mycotoxins are found across a number of foods like nuts, corn, wheat, fruit, cheese, coffee and grapes. Grains are particularly susceptible because mycotoxin-producing molds and fungus naturally grow on the crops and in the soil before they’re harvested. In storage, they can multiply.
Grains are a critical part of plant-based meats, which often contain wheat gluten or seitan or act as a binder or filler. And oat milk, obviously, relies on grain as a main ingredient.
The authors suspect two factors in why plant-based meats had higher contamination compared to plant-based milks: First, they have more ingredients, inviting more opportunity for contamination.
Second, they have less water. Plant-based milks are diluted with water, making any present mycotoxins less concentrated compared to the plant-based meat products.
And while data from this study shows that mycotoxin levels are below regulatory limits, authors say the rules may need revision, at least in Europe where the study was done. They call for limits of certain mycotoxins and foods, monitoring of ingredients like legumes, and more research on how mycotoxins interact with each other to affect human health.
In the US, the FDA has a monitoring program “to help ensure that the foods available for you to buy are not contaminated with mycotoxins,” the agency says.
They focus on seven categories of mycotoxins, including fumonisins, T-2 and HT-2 toxins, and ochratoxin A, which were detected in the study. The others are aflatoxins, deoxynivalenol, patulin and zearalenone.
The FDA tests foods for mycotoxins and has established testing methods and safety limits for certain toxins.
“As an individual consumer, you generally cannot control the presence of mycotoxins in your food,” the FDA says. “The fungi that produce mycotoxins generally grow during crop production and storage.”












