This time, there was no superstar surprise or hot-stove magic.

This time, the Dodgers didn’t pull off another unexpected coup.

Instead, four months after doing whatever it took to acquire Tarik Skubal at this past season’s trade deadline, the club couldn’t do enough to keep him in Los Angeles long term this winter.

On Sunday, Skubal agreed to a staggering nine-year, $450 million contract with the New York Mets, according to a source with knowledge of the situation, earning by far the biggest contract ever guaranteed to a pitcher in MLB history.

The Dodgers, meanwhile, finished as merely a finalist in his free agency sweepstakes –– hardly a surprise given the way their re-signing bid had been trending.

From early on this offseason, the Dodgers’ chances of retaining Skubal quickly started to feel dubious. Even though they traded three top prospects to get him from the Detroit Tigers in a blockbuster deal at the deadline, and raved about his impact on and off the field during a successful three-month stint that saw him cement his status as the best pitcher in baseball, they also knew his bidding would likely stretch beyond their comfort zone.

As usual with star free agents, the Dodgers’ preference was believed to be for a shorter-term structure with the 30-year-old two-time Cy Young Award winner.

But unlike last offseason, when the club netted Kyle Tucker and Edwin Díaz on such deals, Skubal and his agent, Scott Boras, never lowered their sights.

Rather, they took aim at the record $325 million guarantee Yoshinobu Yamamoto got from the Dodgers three winters ago (the previous high mark for an MLB pitcher). They fielded interest from some of the sport’s biggest spenders of recent offseasons, meeting with the Dodgers, Mets, Blue Jays and Padres a week after the General Manager’s meetings (at which point Boras was already boasting of a lucrative “Sku-bull market”). And they ultimately landed a contract from the Mets, as first reported by the New York Post’s Jon Heyman, that will pay Skubal a whopping $50 million annually, in addition to a $45 million signing bonus up front.

The Dodgers did maintain interest in Skubal to the end. And their final bid was not known, at least not immediately.

But for a while now, their chances of keeping Skubal in LA had seemed to be fading.

“He and his family have to make a choice over where they want to spend the next X number of years,” president of baseball operations Andrew Friedman said from the outset of the offseason in late October. “And, obviously, we wish him nothing but the best.”

The Dodgers certainly saw the value of potentially re-signing Skubal, who concluded his fourth-consecutive sub-3.00 ERA season (12-7 record, 2.72 ERA) by winning five of the 10 starts he made with the Dodgers down the stretch (then another as their Game 1 postseason starter in the National League Division Series).

Since 2023, he leads all MLB starters –– minimum 400 innings –– in ERA (2.47), WHIP (0.92) and wins above replacement (21.3, according to Fangraphs).

He has a career 2.13 ERA in eight playoff starts, and would have reaffirmed the Dodgers’ status as having the most star-studded rotation in baseball, alongside Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Blake Snell, Tyler Glasnow and (in some form) Shohei Ohtani.

Just as importantly, he had already proven himself a seamless fit in their clubhouse, forming quick connections with many of his new coaches and teammates; none more so than his new “bestie” in Snell, who made Skubal a personal recruiting pitch after the team’s elimination in the National League Championship Series.

“Incredible organization, incredible teammates, incredible fanbase,” Skubal said that night.

However, the Dodgers were nonetheless wary of a lucrative long-term commitment. 

They already have a bloated future payroll to contend with. They are facing the specter of a salary cap, or other spending restrictions, being included in a new collective bargaining agreement. And they are generally hesitant about signing pitchers deep into their 30s, especially one like Skubal with three elbow surgeries in his past (Tommy John a decade ago, a flexor tendon repair in 2022, a loose body removal during the first half of this year).

Moreover, given the state of the rest of their rotation, Skubal represented more of a luxury to the Dodgers –– whereas his other, more pitching-hungry contenders saw him as a more desperately needed addition.

Put all together, it created a set of circumstances that left the Dodgers increasingly likely to come up short.

On Sunday, it became official, ending Skubal’s Los Angeles tenure after just a three-month stint.

Share.
Exit mobile version